The official website for The Settlers of Catan

Question about The “Age of Darkness” Expansion Odin's Fountain - What happens if I have built both a Town Hall and Odin's Fountain? May I choose both cards for free or do I have to pay 2 resources when choosing the 2nd card?

Answer

Normally, you only may exchange 1 card, but if you have Odin's Fountain, you may exchange 2 cards. Each time you choose a card you must pay the respective costs - usually 2 resources. If you have a Parish Hall, you only pay 1 resource for choosing a card, and if you have a Town Hall, you pay 0 resources.