The official website for The Settlers of Catan

Question about The “Age of Darkness” Expansion Heroes (discarded after using their special effect) - Can Godfrey and Olaf be driven off by the Archer, missionized by the Missionary, or infatuated by Marie?

Answer

Yes and no. Godfrey can be driven off by the Archer and taken over via Marie. Olaf has no strength point and thus is immune to the Archer, but he can be bewitched by Marie. However, in these cases the opponent determines which hero to remove or to offer you, provided that he placed various heroes.